Caravaggio’s Nativity with St. Francis and St. Lawrence

Caravaggio’s Nativity with St. Francis  and St. Lawrence is famous, not just because it is a masterpiece but because it is on the FBI’s 10 Top Art Crimes. The artist has given us a controversial depiction of the Virgin Mary that challenged the doctrines of Catholic church.  Rejecting the exaggerations of the Mannerists (see El Greco’s Annunciation to understand Mannerism) and the perfection of the Renaissance, Caravaggio pursues unflinching realism. While meeting with mixed reviews during his lifetime, this painting caught the eye of a mafia boss in the 1960’s and then was lost to the art world.

The Crime

Caravaggio’s nativity was stolen, cut from it’s frame in 1969. The rumors and stories that have circulated since have never been substantiated. It seems clear that the Mafia was behind the theft, but it is unclear what happened to the painting once stolen. At various times, criminals have tried to negotiate lighter sentences claiming knowledge of the work, according to two of these stories, it was destroyed.  Whatever happened, the original painting has been lost, likely never to be recovered.

This criminal element to the story, somehow seems fitting because much of what we know about the artist is from police records.

Who was Caravaggio?

Michelangelo da Merisi, has always been referred to as Caravaggio, the town he was from. Sharing a name with the ‘divine’ Michelangelo was probably frustrating for such a proud man, so he preferred his new nickname.

Caravaggio was by all accounts an angry, temperamental man, who was frequently in bar brawls, arrested for carrying a sword without a license, and then for killing someone with said sword. Fleeing the police from one location to the next is an ongoing thread in his life. Not surprisingly, he died young ,at 37.

A True Innovator

If we set aside his personal life, and examine his work, everyone agrees, he was one of the most influential artist of the 1600’s.  His innovative use of light, unflinching realism, and the emotion in his religious work is astounding. When we discussed El Greco and the Mannerists we talked about their pushing against the restraints of the Renaissance. Caravaggio pushed back on the Mannerists.

Caravaggio returned to painting things as they appear, but without the perfection and rigidity of Renaissance artists. When he painted Biblical figures he didn’t  clean them up and present them as serene and beautiful with halos. Many were shocked and felt that his paintings were disrespectful. Sometimes patrons, seeing the finished works, refused them.

A new vision of Mary

Caravaggio’s Nativity was painted, just a year before he died, and is one that shocked.

Mary has just given birth, she is disheveled and tired looking, sitting on the ground. Her dress has drifted down one shoulder. This is not a Madonna who already looks as if she is on her way to being enthroned in heaven, but a young girl, tired and recovering from labor.

Shocking the viewers of his day was not just the realism, but the theological message the painting conveyed. Many felt the Virgin had a miraculous birth with no pain and no breaking of her hymen. Not only was Jesus conception miraculous, so was the birth. Caravaggio’s painting challenged that.

The Composition of Caravaggio’s Nativity

In Caravaggio’s Nativity we have Mary, Joseph, the baby Jesus, Saint Lawrence, Saint Francis and a shepherd. In the sky we have the angel with a banner that reads, Glory to God in the Highest. It is an odd contrast, the traditional angel, the saints that are present, and then the non-traditional portrayal of Mary. Including these traditional elements serves to highlight just how unusual his Mary is.

The piece was painted for the Oratory of San Lorenzo in Palermo, Italy. The inclusion of saints was very common, particularly if the saint was associated with the location the work was created for.

In the foreground, we have a shepherd with his backed turned to us. Next to him is an open space. When artists present a back to the viewer we are meant to assume the viewpoint of that person. We are meant to view this scene as if we too are kneeling with the shepherd. In fact, an open place has been left for us to join the circle.

In fact, if we pay attention to our viewpoint, looking straight on at Mary, we can see that we are meant to feel we are kneeling in that open place. We are meant to join the in the act of adoration of the Christ Child.

A new Realism

Caravaggio brought a new realism to his work, and it was new. The Renaissance sought realism in the sense that figures occupied space and appeared fully three dimensional, water glistened, and velvet looked plush….but that realism had strict boundaries. These boundaries were about content, what was appropriate, and how people expected religious subjects to be treated. Figures might have looked real but they were idealized versions. Basically, every Virgin Mary had been ‘photoshopped’ to meet the expectations people had for the mother of God. Caravaggio’s realism was of another kind all together. He painted real human people who were tired, and dusty, and overwhelmed.

The Development of Tenebrism

Caravaggio was a pioneer in the use of light, or maybe more accurately the use of the dark. Chiaroscuro is a technique where light and shade are emphasized, often with the light sourced from one particular location and creating deep shadows. Caravaggio went beyond that developing tenebrism. The name comes from the Italian, meaning dark, gloomy, and mysterious.

Tenebrism was an extreme form of chiaroscuro where the darkness dominates the painting and contrasts sharply with the lighted areas. Only a narrow swath of the painting is in direct light, the rest is deeply shadowed fading into black.

Many artists and art critics of Caravaggio’s day detested his dark, shadowed pictures and the critiques were quite harsh.  Often the truly visionary painters innovations were not valued until after they were gone. This was true of Caravaggio. His new realism interpreted his subjects with dramatic intensity. The poses and expressions are highlighted with the strong effects of light, much as a spotlight would do on a stage. And, much of the painting is black.


If you enjoyed this article, you can read the rest in the series at this link. 

Continue the Advent in Art Journey – Day 23 Tintoretto

Are an Ox, a Rooster, And a Peacock the Perfect Image of the Nativity?


E.H. Gombrich, The Story of Art. (New York, Phaidon Press, 2016)

Professor Sharon Latchaw Hirsh, How to Look at and Understand Great Art, Lecture series, Great Courses

Professor William Koss, History of European Art  Lecture series, Great Courses

Sister Wendy Beckett, The Story of Painting (London, Dorsey Kindersley, 2000)

Marilyn Stokstad, Art History. (New Jersey, Pearson Education, 2005)

National Gallery of Art website  www.nga.gov

Metropolitan Museum of Art website  www.metmuseum.org

The Getty Center www.getty.edu

And thanks to the Met and Wiki commons quality images for public domain art is now much more easily accessible.

Subscribe to KellyBagdanov

Join a generous group of people who help me continue to serve teachers and lovers of art. Click the button below and become a patron!

Top Posts

Affiliate Disclosure

Disclosure: Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, meaning, at no cost to you, I will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.

Download Your Free Curriculum

The Grand Tour Art History Curriculum

Compare 4 works of art from the Italian Renaissance with 4 works from the Byzantine era to begin building the framework we will build on in future lessons. This download will introduce you to the overview portion of the Grand Tour Art History Curriculum and will add your email to our subscription list.

More Articles

Frames and Pedestals, They Matter!

Frames and pedestals add to our first impression of a piece of art. Art is greatly influenced by how the work is displayed and by what surrounds it. Making the effort to consciously take note of these elements can increase our ability to read a work correctly. A closer look at a few sculptures will

Read More »

Sandro Botticelli’s Mystic Nativity

Botticelli’s Mystic Nativity is as beautiful as it is mysterious. With this work we venture into the realm of speculation and conjecture. I hope you find this painting as intriguing as I do. “I, Sandro, painted this picture at the end of the year 1500 in the troubles of Italy.” So begins the inscription at

Read More »